The Truth About Stoning

Transcript

(This transcript is provided for reference only.  It will likely contain grammar and spelling mistakes.)

Hey what’s up guys?

You know Stoning is a pretty misunderstood topic.

Most people probably assume as soon as someone did something wrong people would bend down and grab the closest rock and go to town on the person until they were dead.

But that couldn’t be farther from the truth though.

The truth is, there were rules that were followed in regards to hearing cases, passing judgment, and carrying out penalties including stoning someone to death.

We’ll get into all that later, but first I want to touch on some of the verses that show that stoning a person to death was something commanded by YHWH and not just a barbaric practice.

Let’s look at Exodus 19:12-13

 

Slide1

Now let’s jump to Leviticus 20:2

 

Slide2

And finally, Leviticus 24:14-16

 

Slide3

In each one of these verses we just read, YHWH is the one commanding death by stoning.

It was YHWH who created capital punishment, not man.

 

Slide4

As far as stoning goes, there were only certain crimes or sins that warranted stoning someone to death.

Here is a list of all the sins that were punishable by death.

 

Slide5

 

Slide6

 

Slide7

If a person was found guilty of any of these sins they were to be put to death and stoning was the method most often used.

Like I said earlier though, a person could not just pick up rocks and start throwing them at someone!

There was a court system in place and rules that had to be followed

Slide8

Slide9

So on top of these three things,

the witnesses who testified against a person were required to cast the first stones,

if the guilty person was still alive after that,

then and only then could the other people at the city gate pick up stones and throw them at the guilty person.

We see this in Deuteronomy 17:7

 

Slide10

There were even rules concerning bearing false witness in a case.

 

Slide 11

After looking at all this information, we can start to paint a more accurate picture about what stoning was really like in the Ancient Near East.

Here is one last piece of information though.

 

Slide12

Now we should be able to see that stoning was not a case of random people picking up rocks and killing someone when they did something wrong.

There were rules in place that had to be followed.

There had to be no less than two witnesses.

There had to be a trial held for the witnesses to be heard.

No partiality was to be shown to the accused or accuser, whether they were a native born or a foreigner living in the land.

If you gave false testimony you were given the same punishment as the falsely accused, which would have been death.

If someone was found guilty then and only then could the two witnesses cast the first stones. After that other people would cast stones until the guilty person was dead.

So, we can see that the idea that many people have about stoning is just not correct.

That’s why many people like to ask if we stone our kids when they learn we follow Torah.

The answer is NO!

We’re not under a biblical form of government so we can’t just go out in the back yard and stone our kids.  If we did we would actually be breaking Torah.

And that’s the same situation Y’shua was in in the story of the adulterous woman.

Some people believe this story is an example of Y’shua showing that he came to bring grace and love and that the old law no longer applies.

Let’s read this story and then we’ll break it apart to see exactly what is really going on.

 

Slide13

 

Slide14

Unless we understand the Torah and the instructions concerning adultery and stoning, it does seem like Y’shua is replacing the Torah with a more loving way.  There is a major clue in this story, though, that lets us know that things are not exactly the way they appear.

Verse 6 says

 

Slide15

They were trying to trap him…so what exactly does that mean?

In order to have the full picture, we have to go back to the Torah to see exactly what the instructions were for stoning someone for committing adultery.

 

Slide16

So we can see that BOTH the man and woman have to be put to death.

And based on everything we’ve covered already about trials, witnesses, and the process that had to take place before someone could be stoned…

Hopefully, things should be more clear now.

Now we can start to see exactly how they were trying to trap Y’shua.

Where was the man at?

Where were the two witnesses?

Why was this not taken to the judges to be heard?

If Y’shua had cast that first stone, or even if he had given them the OK to stone her, then he would have been violating Torah.

That’s how they were trying to trap him.

But, He didn’t fall for it.

Instead, he did like he always did when people tried to trap him…he turned things around on them by saying…

 

Slide17

After he said that, one by one they all left.

By not stoning the woman, he was actually upholding the Torah, not going against it!

Think about this…

If Y’shua broke Torah then that disqualifies him from being the spotless lamb and his death means nothing.

 

We hope this teaching has been a blessing and remember…

STAY THIRSTY FOR THE PURE MILK OF THE WORD!

Check This Out

 

HomeschoolingTorahAd

Posted on November 14, 2015 in Ancient Near East, Answering Tough Questions, Confronting Mainstream Christians, The Torah Today, Videos

Share the Story

About the Author

Chris lives on the Mississippi Gulf Coast with his wife and daughter. He has a heart for reaching people with the truth about Torah and is dedicated to seeking, teaching and living out the truth of the Word, from Genisis to Revelation. Chris grew up in Church and ran the gambit from Baptist to Non-denominational, but he admittedly was just a "pew warmer." His walk didn't truly start until a close friend asked him a simple, yet profound question. "What is Gods name?"

Responses (3)

  1. Steve Guerra
    November 24, 2015 at 11:44 am · Reply

    You ask “why was this not taken to the judges to be heard?”
    Jesus was a judge “Emmanu-el” (“el” means judge but is translated god). The judges at the gate are “Elohim” (Ex 21:6).

    If you can’t read Hebrew “Young’s Literal Translation” renders Ex 21:6 –
    Then hath his lord brought him nigh unto “God”, and hath brought him nigh unto the door,
    (Even this is wrong it should say “unto the gods”)

    All other translations render Ex 21:6 –
    then his master must take him before the “judges”. He shall take him to the door.

  2. Steve Guerra
    November 24, 2015 at 1:14 pm · Reply

    In the case of adultery a Torah judge, in this case Jesus, only has to listen to witness testimony. Torah has already ordained the penalty for adultery (Lev 20:10). The witnesses had already testified (John 8:4).

    Jesus said to them, “You, who won’t miss, be the first to throw a stone at her.” (John 8:7)

    Jesus upholds Deut 22:22 and Zac 7:9, because the first blow is the death blow, there is no suffering.

    Because of the double entendre “You who is without sin, cast the first stone” the witnesses were reminded of Deut 19:19, and chose to walk away instead.

  3. Deirdre Cline
    May 9, 2016 at 5:04 am · Reply

    Steve Guerra, where was the man? Both were to be stoned.
    How did these accusers know What She was Doing? Perhaps they were doing it too?
    These guys were looking to get Messiah in a bind, they were not considering Isaiah’s prophesied name/title.

Join the Conversation

Back to Top